Paul Dietrich's Global Investing Trends Report

Active Investments And Buy-And-Hold Investments

Posted September 27, 2007 · 0 Comments

Dear Paul,


How do I explain to my clients, the difference between “ACTIVE INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT” and “BUY-AND- HOLD INVESTMENT MANAGEMENT?”


An important new academic study, “SECTOR ROTATION AND MONETARY CONDITIONS,” which is slated for publication in the prestigious JOURNAL OF INVESTING early next year, gives new academic confirmation to the FOXHALL investment management strategy of “active investment management.”


The study was conducted by Robert Johnson, managing director of the education division of the CFA (Chartered Financial Analyst) Institute in Charlottesville, Virginia, along with co-authors C. Mitchell Conover, associate professor of finance at the University of Richmond in Virginia; Gerald Jensen, professor of finance at Northern Illinois University; and Jeffrey Mercer, professor of finance at Texas Tech University.




As you know, the FOXHALL investment strategy consists of three components:


GLOBAL DIVERSIFICATION:  Almost every academic study has concluded that a global investment portfolio is safer, less risky and more diversified than putting all your eggs in one basket-even if that one basket is the U.S. stock market.  We have seen over the past two months just how volatile the U.S. stock market can be.  Our clients gain the advantage of global diversification and exposure to the fastest growing markets in the world.


DEFENSIVE INVESTMENT STRATEGY:  FOXHALL has created and uses a proprietary, methodology and discipline that identifies major stock market corrections, bear markets and recessions at an early stage.  Once this computer model “trigger” is hit, FOXHALL decisively moves client investments to bonds, money market funds or other defensive investments in order to protect our client’s investment principal. 


OFFENSIVE INVESTMENT STRATEGY:  When the stock market is going up in a long-term “bull market,” FOXHALL stays invested in the stock market.  Foxhall continuously monitors each of its investments and as the stock market and economies are outperforming the market at any given time.  This investment technique is called “sector rotation” by investment professionals.




The upcoming JOURNAL OF INVESTING study gives academic confirmation to the FOXHALL “OFFENSIVE / DEFENSIVE” investment strategy that we have used for years.  The study states that as the U.S. economy changes, Federal Reserve policy changes with it.  We saw that happen this month, when the Federal Reserve recognized that the economy was weakening because of the housing crisis and they cut interest rates.


This new study concludes that as the economy changes (and you can track those changes by watching changes in Federal Reserve interest rate changes) a “SECTOR ROTATION” strategy (like we use at FOXHALL CAPITAL) “could have substantially improved portfolio performance over a broad-market-index portfolio over the past 33 year’s according to the study.




The results indicate that investors would be well served to modify sector exposures during different monetary-policy environments,” said coauthor Robert Johnson, in a September 17, 2007 interview in INVESTMENT NEWS.


Mr. Johnson went on to say that during phases of the economic cycle, “Investors would have improved performance by placing greater emphasis on cyclical stocks during periods of Fed easing and overweighting defensive stocks during periods of Fed tightening.”


“Cyclical stocks did particularly well during expansive periods,” Mr. Johnson added,

“returning an average of 20.27%, but fared poorly during restrictive periods, returning

an average of just 2.25%.  Non-cyclical stocks performed much better than cyclicals during restrictive periods, the study shows, returning 10.24%, but underperformed cyclicals during expansive periods, returning 14.65%.”




These results, Mr. Johnson argued, “demonstrate that investors could improve their portfolio’s performance” by increasing or decreasing exposure to certain sectors depending on the economic cycle.


This is just one more academic study debunking the old and out-dated academic presumption that a “buy-and-hold” investing is the way to invest for the long-run.


“Buy-and-hold” investing simply means investing all of your money in say an S&P 500

INDEX FUND that follows the broad stock market.  The strategy requires that you hold that S&P 500 INDEX FUND at all times, even if the economy is going into a recession.


Unfortunately, the reason this strategy doesn’t work is that clients remember the last

“bear market” in 2000, 2001 and 2002 when the S&P 500 INDEX dropped almost 50% during that period.  Currently the S&P 500 INDEX is still not back to its 2000 high price and it is now seven years later.  That means after seven years, you still haven’t earned back what you lost in the last “bear market.”



Most investors would prefer to not lose most of their principal every time we have a cyclical “bear market” or recession.  They would prefer an “active investment

management” strategy that moves their investments to bonds, cash or other defensive investments.


That is the conclusion of this latest study and it is always nice to have a major academic study confirm that the investment principles we use at FOXHALL CAPITAL are based on a strategy that works and overtime will, as the study says, “substantially improved portfolio performance over a broad-market-index portfolio.”


Until next week …


-Paul Dietrich



Disclosure:  The opinions and portfolio information provided in the Foxhall Global Outlook are subject to change at any time, and are not to be construed as advice for any individual nor as an offer or solicitation of an offer for purchase or sale of any security.  Client accounts may differ from model allocations due to many reasons.  All investment strategies offer the potential for loss as well as gain.  Individuals should consult with their financial professional to determine an investment strategy appropriate for their objectives, risk level, and time horizon prior to investing.  Past performance is not a guarantee of similar future performance.


Back to Blog


Subscribe to my blog via RSS or email.


About Paul Dietrich
Paul Dietrich is the Chairman, CEO and Co-Chief Investment Officer of Foxhall Capital Management, Inc. (Foxhall).  Foxhall currently manages investments for individuals, mutual funds and private institutions throughout the United States. Paul Dietrich is also a portfolio manager to a publicly traded mutual fund, the Foxhall Global Trends Fund.
Learn more about Paul Dietrich

Latest Video:

Paul Dietrich on FOX Business


protect your investments diversified great depression public relations SP 500 index Paul Dietrich Asian growth investors gold global economy Long-term bull market Asian economies supply & demand megatrends DUAL INVESTMENT STRATEGY ecomomy Indexes Foxhall Global Trends Fund Nassim Taleb protectionism investment economy U.S. stock market developed markets risk management. investment principal export growth asia tipping point global political issues buying power

August 2013
July 2013
May 2013
April 2013
March 2013
October 2012
September 2012
July 2012
June 2012
May 2012
March 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
January 2011
December 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
March 2010
January 2010
November 2009
September 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007